Skip to content
Bifröst Orbit
Sign in

Comparisons

CMS Orbit vs Payload: a framework in your app, or a CMS ready to use

Payload is an MIT-licensed CMS and app framework that runs inside your Next.js project. CMS Orbit is ready to use, with SSO, reviews and co-editing from €49, where Payload puts them on Enterprise. How they differ and how to choose.

Bifröst Orbit team

13 min read

On this page

Payload is an open-source CMS and application framework written in TypeScript. It installs into a Next.js app, so your CMS and your website can be one project, one deploy and one codebase. Developers love it for that, and with good reason.

CMS Orbit takes the other road. It's a headless CMS that's ready to use, run by us in the EU. Editors get a visual editor, real-time co-editing, reviews, SEO, accessibility checks and regions from the first day. Your website reads from it over REST or GraphQL, or through our SDKs.

Here's how the two compare, where Payload is the better choice and where CMS Orbit is.

Updated in November 2026: Since we first published this comparison, CMS Orbit has added real-time co-editing on every plan and Gravity, search by meaning.

The short answer

  • Choose Payload if: you're a TypeScript and Next.js team, you want the CMS defined in code inside your own app, you might use it as an app back end too, and you're happy to host it.
  • Choose CMS Orbit if: you want a CMS you don't have to host or build. Editors change content types and publish safely without a developer. Co-editing, SSO, reviews and an audit log come on every plan, from Starter at €49 a month.

How each one works

Payload is MIT licensed. It needs Node 20.9 or later and MongoDB, Postgres or SQLite. Collections, globals, fields and access rules are all defined in code, and blocks fields give editors reusable layout sections. As well as REST and GraphQL, Payload has a Local API that reads the database directly from your Node code, with no network call. Because it's a framework, you can build far more than a website on it.

Payload is now part of Figma. Its FAQ says Figma is committed to keeping the open-source core. Payload runs inside your own Next.js app, so you choose and run its hosting. One-click templates exist for Vercel and Cloudflare.

CMS Orbit is a service. The content model lives in the CMS, editors work in a web app, and your website or app reads published content from the delivery API. Developers still get a lot: GraphQL, a Management API with full create, update and delete, and signed webhooks with retries. There are SDKs for JavaScript and TypeScript (with React and Next.js helpers), PHP, Swift and Kotlin. 11 quickstarts run from Next.js and Astro to Laravel and SwiftUI. See how it works.

The work Payload leaves to you

Payload's freedom comes with the usual self-hosting jobs:

  • Hosting: a server or platform, a database, file storage and monitoring, with no hosted Payload option for new projects at the moment.
  • Updates: Payload releases often. Upgrading means testing your config, plugins and front end together.
  • Backups: yours to set up and test, on your database and your file storage.
  • SSO and publishing workflows: both are Enterprise features, through a demo request with no public price.
  • Editor features: SEO and redirects come as official plugins you add and configure. Editors usually need a developer to add a field or content type, because the schema is code.

For a developer-led team building something custom, that's often a fair trade. For a marketing team that publishes every day, it can mean waiting on developers.

Count the whole bill too. Payload's licence is free, but hosting, the database, file storage, monitoring, backups, upgrades and developer time are not. SSO and publishing workflows then need an Enterprise agreement on top.

With CMS Orbit there are no servers, upgrades, backups or security patches for you to run. Hourly and nightly encrypted backups and a hot standby with automatic failover are part of every plan, Starter included. A mirror of your published pages, menus and banners sits in Amazon S3 behind Cloudflare. If CMS Orbit can't be reached, the SDK switches to it, so your website stays up.

Content modelling: in code or in the CMS

Payload's code-first model is type-safe and lives in version control. That's a real strength: reviews happen in pull requests, and nothing changes without a deploy.

CMS Orbit lets admins create content types, collections and components in the CMS without code or a deploy. There are 22 core field types, plus 13 that pick live data from other Orbit tools, such as trips, products and services. Fields can show only when another has a value, carry validation rules or differ by region. Price and promotion fields can be protected, and AI agents can never change them.

Developers who want the same discipline as Payload can keep the schema in the repository. CI syncs it through the Management API, with a dry run first. npx cms-orbit generate writes types for TypeScript, PHP, Swift and Kotlin. See schema as code. CMS Orbit has no JSON or location field types yet.

Editing, preview and versions

Payload has live preview built in. Versions, drafts and autosave are opt-in per collection. The admin shows a diff between versions, and you can restore through the UI or any API.

CMS Orbit has a visual editor on your real website on every plan, at desktop, tablet and phone widths. You click a component in the preview to edit it and see changes as you type. Version history renders the old and new versions side by side on the website, with a list of every field that changed. Shared sections are edited once and update every page. Deleted pages go to a bin, and only the Owner can erase for good. See live preview with Next.js and undoing mistakes.

CMS OrbitPage editor
The Northwilds home page in the CMS Orbit editor, with the hero selected in the live preview of northwilds.com and its fields on the right.

Editing together

Payload lists multiplayer editing as coming soon on Enterprise. CMS Orbit has real-time co-editing today, on every plan from Starter at €49 a month. Several people work in the same page at once and see each other's cursors and typing, in the field and in the preview.

  • Field-level locks: A field someone is typing in is theirs, and frees up five seconds after they stop.
  • Safe undo: Undo only takes back your own changes.
  • Follow and chat: Follow a colleague, send a link to join you, and talk in a page chat with @mentions.
  • Offline editing: Your changes are kept and merge with everyone else's when the connection returns.
  • Agents and APIs live: Changes from AI agents and the Management API appear for everyone straight away.

See editing a page together.

Governance

Payload's access control is detailed: document, field and operation level, defined in code. SSO and publishing workflows are on Enterprise.

CMS Orbit includes these on every plan, from Starter at €49 a month, with no code:

  • Single sign-on: Microsoft Entra ID, Google Workspace, OpenID Connect or SAML, with SCIM and passkeys.
  • Reviews: A reviewer approves one exact version, and nobody approves their own changes.
  • Roles and audit: Six built-in roles, access limited by region and an audit log that includes AI agents and API keys.
  • Approved claims: Legal wording per region, placed by key. Change it once and every page updates within about a minute.

Growth adds multi-step approvals with steps by role and region, review-by dates with reminders, releases, custom roles and an emergency banner, which an Admin or Owner pins on every page with a required reason in the audit log. Read reviews, approvals and an audit trail.

SEO, accessibility and languages

Payload has field-level localisation in the core and official SEO and Redirects plugins.

CMS Orbit has an SEO workspace on every plan, with no plugin to add: a health score per page and site, quick wins, a search-result preview and automatic redirects. It tracks 404s and broken links, builds hreflang automatically, checks the live website's language links daily and pings IndexNow. The accessibility checker reads content as you type and runs axe-core on the rendered page. It offers one-click fixes and a publish gate that can warn or block. Regions carry their own address prefix, time zone and currency, and DeepL suggestions are included. See SEO built into CMS Orbit and accessible by default publishing.

CMS OrbitSEO in the editor
The SEO tab in the CMS Orbit editor: a search preview of the Northwilds home page, with the title and description and the length of each.

Payload offers static A/B testing on Enterprise. CMS Orbit runs A/B experiments from Growth, at €199 a month, on a component or a whole page, with up to four variants. Goals include clicks, visits, forms and events from other Orbit tools, such as a booking paid. Results are Bayesian, with the chance to beat the original and a sample ratio warning. The winner goes into the draft and through normal review. A cookieless mode respects Do Not Track and GPC.

Gravity, search by meaning, is on every plan. A search for 'warm clothes for winter' finds Northwilds' down jackets, in any language. Your website gets /search and /related endpoints, and editors see possible duplicates. It runs on our servers in the EU, so content isn't sent to a third party. See search by meaning with Gravity.

AI agents

Payload has an official MCP plugin and lists Enterprise AI features. CMS Orbit's MCP server has 28 tools on every plan and works with Claude, Cursor, VS Code or any MCP client. Agents find and draft content, write SEO text, set alt text, run checks and submit work for review. They never publish, delete other people's work or change prices, settings or schemas. Everything an agent writes is marked Drafted by AI, waits for someone else's approval and is audited. See connect Claude, Cursor or VS Code.

Moving from Payload

Our Payload migration guide maps collections and blocks to CMS Orbit. npx cms-orbit import brings in entries with a dry run first and can run again safely. Images keep their alt text, translations stay linked and redirects are added.

Price

Payload is free to self-host. Your costs are hosting, your team's time and, if you need SSO or workflows, an Enterprise agreement.

CMS Orbit is a flat price per organisation: Starter €49 a month (€41 billed yearly) with 5 members, Growth €199 (€166 yearly) with 15, Enterprise from €790. Prices exclude VAT. Hosting, backups, co-editing and SSO are included, and Orbit, the foundation underneath, is free. See pricing.

What you get on Starter

Starter at €49 a month includes several things Payload keeps for Enterprise or leaves to plugins:

  • Real-time co-editing, page chat, comments and offline merge
  • SSO, SCIM, passkeys and an audit log
  • Reviews before publishing, and scheduling in each region's time zone
  • The SEO workspace and the accessibility checker with a publish gate
  • A visual editor on your real website, with version compare
  • Approved claims and 35 field types, 13 of them live data from other Orbit tools
  • REST, GraphQL, the Management API and signed webhooks
  • 28 MCP tools for AI agents, and Gravity search by meaning
  • EU hosting, hourly backups, automatic failover and the offline mirror

Growth adds A/B experiments, multi-step approvals, releases, campaigns, review-by dates and custom roles.

Side by side

FeatureCMS OrbitPayload
What it isManaged headless CMSOpen-source CMS and app framework (MIT)
HostingRun for you in the EURuns in your own app, on hosting you choose
What the price coversHosting, upgrades, patches, backups, failover and every feature in the planThe software. Hosting, upkeep and Enterprise features are extra
Upgrades, backups and patchesOurs, with hourly backups and automatic failoverYours to run
If the CMS is downA mirror keeps published pages servingDepends on your hosting
Content modelIn the CMS, or as code synced from CIIn code, TypeScript
Live previewEvery plan, click a component to editBuilt in
Real-time co-editingEvery plan from €49, with field locks and offline mergeComing soon on Enterprise
VersionsVisual compare on the real website, every planOpt-in versions with a diff and restore
Reviews and approvalsReviews on every plan from €49. Multi-step by role and region on GrowthPublishing workflows on Enterprise
SEO and redirectsBuilt in, every planOfficial plugins
Single sign-onEntra ID, Google Workspace, OpenID Connect and SAML, every plan from €49Enterprise
A/B testingBayesian experiments on Growth, €199 a monthStatic A/B testing on Enterprise
AI agents over MCP28 tools on every plan, drafts only, another person approvesOfficial MCP plugin
APIs and SDKsREST, GraphQL, Management API, webhooks and 4 SDKs with type generationREST, GraphQL and a Local API
CommerceCommerce Orbit, a separate satelliteEcommerce plugin in beta, Stripe only
Price modelFlat per organisation, from €49 a monthFree to self-host. Enterprise on request

Where Payload is stronger

  • Lives in your app: One Next.js project for the CMS and the website, with a Local API that skips the network.
  • Code is the only source: Schema and access rules live in your TypeScript, and every change goes through your normal review and deploy. CMS Orbit has schema as code too, synced to a hosted service.
  • More than a CMS: It works as a back end for apps, not only websites.
  • Open source: MIT licence, host anywhere, change anything.
  • Official plugins: Form Builder, Multi-Tenant, Import/Export and more. CMS Orbit builds SEO, redirects, search and import in, but has no plugin system.
  • Database choice: MongoDB, Postgres or SQLite.

Where CMS Orbit is stronger

  • Enterprise features from €49: SSO, reviews and real-time co-editing on Starter. Payload puts SSO and publishing workflows on Enterprise, with co-editing still to come.
  • Ready without building or hosting: No servers, upgrades, backups or security patches to run. Hourly backups, automatic failover and an offline mirror keep the website up.
  • Editors work without developers: New content types, components and pages without a deploy, in a visual editor on the real website.
  • Co-editing today: Several people in one page on every plan, with cursors, field locks, chat and offline merge.
  • Governance without code: Reviews, SSO, SCIM, approved claims and an audit log on every plan. Growth adds approval steps by role and region, review-by dates and an audited emergency banner.
  • SEO and accessibility in the core: An SEO workspace with automatic hreflang, and an accessibility checker with a publish gate. No plugins to maintain.
  • Experiments and search included: Bayesian A/B tests on Growth rather than Enterprise, and Gravity search by meaning, hosted in the EU.
  • AI with hard limits: 28 MCP tools, drafts only, another person approves.
  • Many front ends: SDKs for JavaScript, PHP, Swift and Kotlin, so the same content serves a Laravel site or an iPhone app.
  • EU hosting: Servers in Spain, a recovery copy in France and files in Ireland. See the trust centre.

What changes when you add satellites

Payload can grow into a lot, if your developers build it. CMS Orbit's satellites are already built, and they share Orbit: one free sign-in, one set of people and roles, one audit trail per tool and events that pass between them.

At Northwilds, our demo outdoor brand, a trip page shows live departures from Travel Orbit, the Fjell GTX boot comes with live stock from Commerce Orbit, and the Oslo shop at Karl Johans gate 12 takes boot fittings through Booking Orbit. Jobs come from Careers Orbit, reviews from Presence Orbit (Trustpilot and file import today, Google and Facebook coming) and visitor numbers from Insights Orbit. Payload's Ecommerce plugin covers products, carts and orders with Stripe, but it's in beta, with no shipping, tax or subscriptions, and there's nothing for trips, bookings, hiring or reviews.

northwilds.com/gear/fjell-gtx-boot/
The Fjell GTX boot on northwilds.com, at €219 with an Add to bag button, free repairs for life and its weight, upper, lining and sole.

Without satellites, that's five or six separate tools wired together by hand.

Who should choose which

  • Payload: TypeScript and Next.js developers building a custom site or app, who want the CMS in their codebase and are comfortable running it.
  • CMS Orbit: Teams who want editors to own the website, working together with governance, SEO and accessibility from day one. EU hosting and nothing to maintain. A strong fit if you also run trips, a shop, bookings, hiring or reviews.

Every plan will start with a 14-day free trial, no card needed. Trials open soon. In the meantime, explore CMS Orbit or talk to us.

Read next: How to choose a headless CMS in 2026, CMS Orbit vs Strapi and CMS Orbit vs Sanity.

Based on each product's public documentation and pricing in November 2026. Products change, so check the latest details.

Sources

Comparisons

CMS Orbit vs Hygraph: GraphQL federation or a complete website CMS

Hygraph is a GraphQL-native CMS built to federate content from other systems. CMS Orbit is a complete CMS for websites, with scheduling, SSO, an audit log, reviews, SEO and accessibility on every plan from €49. Hygraph keeps scheduling, SSO and audit logs for Enterprise.

12 min read

Comparisons

CMS Orbit vs Directus: a data platform or a website CMS

Directus puts APIs and an admin app on top of your own SQL database. CMS Orbit is a CMS built for websites, ready to use, with co-editing, reviews, SSO, SEO and accessibility checks on every plan from €49. What each does well and the work each leaves to you.

12 min read

Comparisons

CMS Orbit vs Prismic: two ways to let marketers build pages

Prismic and CMS Orbit both let marketers build pages from developer-made components. Prismic starts cheaper. From €49, CMS Orbit adds real-time co-editing, SSO, an audit log, SEO, accessibility checks and EU hosting.

11 min read

See it with your own team.

Orbit is free. Try CMS Orbit for 14 days with your own content, no card needed, or ask us anything.

Talk to us