Skip to content
Bifröst Orbit
Sign in

Comparisons

Insights Orbit vs Google Analytics and Plausible

Google Analytics is free and deep, Plausible is simple and private. Insights Orbit is cookieless too, and adds alerts, plain summaries and numbers inside your CMS from its first plan.

Bifröst Orbit team

9 min read

On this page

Most websites run Google Analytics 4 because it's free and it's what everyone knows. A growing number have moved to cookieless tools such as Plausible, to avoid tracking people and to keep data in the EU. Matomo and Fathom are popular choices too, and we mention them along the way.

Insights Orbit is cookieless website analytics, built into CMS Orbit and the other satellites. It tells you what changed and why, alerts you when something breaks and puts the numbers beside the page you're editing. This post compares it with GA4 and Plausible, including where it costs more.

Insights OrbitOverview
Insights Orbit's overview for northwilds.com: visitors, visits, page views, average visit, bounce rate and goal completions, each against the period before.

The short answer

  • Choose Google Analytics 4: If you advertise with Google Ads and want analytics tied to Ads and BigQuery, and you're happy to run a consent banner.
  • Choose Plausible: If you want open source analytics you can host yourself, or one simple page for a single small site at the lowest price.
  • Choose Insights Orbit: If you want cookieless numbers that come with answers: alerts, plain summaries, goals filled in by your other tools and analytics inside CMS Orbit. Alerts, server events and free single sign-on (SSO) come on every plan.

GA4 uses cookies, so sites in the EU need a consent banner. Visitors who decline are missing from your reports or modelled. In February 2022, the French regulator CNIL ruled that one site's use of Google Analytics transferred data to the US unlawfully, after complaints by noyb. Austria's regulator had come to a similar view first. The legal position has moved since, so take advice for your own site.

Plausible and Insights Orbit are both cookieless. Insights Orbit counts visits with a daily hash of the IP address and browser, using a secret that changes at midnight. Nobody can be followed from one day to the next, and IP addresses are never stored. Do Not Track and Global Privacy Control are respected, and bots and referrer spam are left out. The overview says how many visits were left out on purpose.

We're open about one thing: Insights Orbit is built to count without a banner, but the law isn't settled, and German regulators disagree with each other. If you want to be cautious, one setting holds every event until your banner agrees. Site settings also give you an opt-out page to link from your privacy notice. See how visits are counted.

Prices and data kept

GA4 is free. Analytics 360 is paid and quoted. Standard properties keep event data for 2 or 14 months, and 360 adds 26, 38 or 50 months.

Plausible prices in US dollars: Starter $9 a month (1 site, 10,000 page views), Growth $14 (3 sites, 3 members), Business $19 (10 sites, with funnels, revenue and the API) and a custom Enterprise plan. Higher page view tiers cost more, and data is kept for as long as you subscribe.

Insights Orbit counts events. Starter is €19 a month for 100,000 events, 2 sites, 10 goals and 13 months of data. Growth is €79 a month for 2 million events, 10 sites, 50 goals and 3 years of data, with funnels, journeys, segments and revenue. Enterprise keeps up to 5 years.

Three things hold on every plan. Your team isn't capped by plan, so the whole marketing team can read the numbers. Events are never cut off over your limit: owners get a note at 80% and 100%. When a plan ends, nothing is deleted, and every report stays readable.

Reports you can act on

GA4 is deep, and many teams find it hard to read. Plausible is the opposite: one clear page. Insights Orbit aims for answers instead of reports, and the first ones come on Starter.

  • Last week in a few words: On every plan, a short summary of the week from its numbers only. When AI writes it, it's kept only if every number checks against the data.
  • Alerts on every plan: A note in the Orbit bell when visits fall or rise sharply, or when a goal stops being completed. Every new site gets two suggested alerts, so a broken form doesn't go unnoticed.
  • Summary emails: A weekly or monthly email with six key numbers, a chart and a PDF to forward. Starter includes one, Growth has no limit.
  • Worth a look: On Growth, a list of what stands out, such as a page losing search visits or a busy page where nobody completes a goal.
  • Goals, funnels and journeys: Goals look back over past data, so a new goal fills in at once. Growth adds funnels of 2 to 8 steps and journeys, a diagram of the pages before and after any page.
  • Labels without code: On Growth, click a button on your live website and name it, and its clicks count as an event. No developer, no release.
  • AI assistants as a source: Visits from AI assistants show as their own channel.
  • Shared dashboards: Read-only links with an optional password and an end date, for an agency or a board. Starter includes one link at a time.

Built into your CMS

GA4, Plausible and Matomo all sit outside your CMS. Insights Orbit sits inside CMS Orbit, on every Insights Orbit plan. Follow a CMS Orbit website in one click, and the SDK adds the script with one component. Each page in the editor gets a Performance panel with visitors, sources, scroll depth and goals. Page lists get a Visitors column you can sort by.

Every publish, release and campaign is marked on the charts, so you can see what a change did. Banner and popup variants show their clicks side by side, with a significance check. A/B tests from CMS Orbit can split any report by variant, so you see where each variant's visitors went next. On Growth, Search Console data appears beside your pages. Read cookieless analytics next to your pages and the docs.

Insights Orbit works on other sites too. The script is about 2 KB and handles single-page apps, and you can serve it from your own domain so fewer ad blockers stop it. Payments and other server events go through the server API, on every plan, and count in goals next to website events.

Insights OrbitGoogle Analytics 4Plausible
PriceFrom €19 a monthFree, 360 quotedFrom $9 a month
CookiesNoneYesNone
Data kept13 months, 3 years or up to 5 years by plan2 or 14 months, more on 360While you subscribe
Sites on the first plan2Not compared here1
Team membersNot capped by planNot compared here3 on Growth
Alerts and weekly summaryEvery plan, from StarterNot compared hereNot compared here
Funnels and revenueOn Growth, with journeys and segmentsNot compared hereOn Business
Inside your CMS editorYes, with CMS Orbit, on every planNoNo
Google Ads integrationNoYesNot compared here
SSOEntra ID, Google Workspace, OpenID Connect and SAML, free on every planNot compared hereEnterprise only
HostingGermany and Spain, with a recovery copy in FranceNot compared hereMade and hosted in the EU
Open sourceNoNoYes, self-hostable

Where Google Analytics and Plausible are stronger

  • Price: GA4 is free. Plausible starts at $9 a month for a single site, below Insights Orbit's €19 for two.
  • Advertising: GA4 ties into Google Ads and BigQuery. Insights Orbit has no Google Ads integration. It reads Search Console on Growth, and from Growth backs up raw events to your own bucket every night.
  • Open source: Plausible is open source and can be self-hosted. Insights Orbit can't be self-hosted.
  • Heatmaps and recordings: Matomo offers heatmaps, session recordings and a tag manager, and can be self-hosted. Insights Orbit has scroll depth and labelled clicks, but no heatmaps or recordings.
  • Following people across days: Without cookies, Insights Orbit recognises a visitor for one day, so funnels count per visit. Funnels and retention across days need known users, on Enterprise.
  • Mobile apps: There's no native iOS or Android SDK yet. Apps send events through your own server, with step-by-step guides for both.

Fathom is similar to Plausible. It starts at $15 a month for 100,000 page views and 50 sites. EU visitors' IP addresses are hashed on servers run by BunnyWay in Slovenia, and the anonymous data is stored in the US.

Where Insights Orbit is stronger

  • Inside CMS Orbit: Numbers sit beside the page you're editing, with publishes, campaigns and experiments marked on the charts.
  • Answers from the first plan: Alerts, the weekly summary and one summary email come with Starter. Summaries are checked against the data before you see them.
  • Goals with no tagging: Orders, appointments, applications and reviews from the other satellites arrive as events, on every plan.
  • Free SSO on every plan: Plausible keeps SSO for Enterprise, and Matomo puts it in its Enterprise bundle. Orbit includes single sign-on with Entra ID, Google Workspace, OpenID Connect or SAML for free.
  • Room for the whole team: Plans count events and sites, not people. Viewers, Editors and Admins each see what their role allows.
  • Cookieless by default, in the EU: Hosted in Germany and Spain, with a recovery copy in France, and never sent to Google. A consent mode is there if you want one.
  • Your data, your way: CSV downloads on every plan. On Growth, a raw event API and GraphQL, and every day's raw events backed up to your own bucket.
  • Read-only AI access: On Growth, assistants such as Claude can read your reports over MCP, never single visitors.
  • An audit trail and a bin: Changes, shares and downloads are recorded, and deleted sites, goals and dashboards can be restored.

What changes on one platform

Insights Orbit works on any website. On Orbit, the free foundation, the other satellites send it goals without any tagging.

  • Orders with revenue: Each Commerce Orbit order arrives as an 'Order placed' event with its total, and no customer data. Revenue reports come with Growth.
  • Appointments and applications: Booking Orbit sends 'Appointment booked' with its price, and Careers Orbit counts 'Applied' on its hosted career pages.
  • Reviews: Presence Orbit sends 'Review received' with the rating.
  • Not yet from Travel: Travel Orbit's booking pages are counted, but bookings don't reach Insights Orbit as goals yet.
  • Events through Orbit Exchange: A goal can start an Orbit Flow or a webhook, and alerts land in the same Orbit bell as everything else.
  • One sign-in: Your team uses the same Orbit account for CMS Orbit and Insights Orbit, with passkeys, roles and an audit trail. Orbit itself costs nothing. Read why Orbit is free.

Who should choose which

If Google Ads drives your business, GA4 is the natural choice, banner and all. If you want open source analytics you can host yourself, or one simple page for one small site, Plausible is a good choice. If you need heatmaps and session recordings, look at Matomo.

Choose Insights Orbit for cookieless numbers that warn you when something breaks, explain the week in plain words and sit next to your pages. It does most for teams on CMS Orbit, Commerce, Booking or Careers, where goals fill in by themselves. Every plan will start with a 14-day free trial with no card. Trials open soon, so for now talk to us or read the Insights Orbit page and the plans and limits.

Based on each product's public documentation and pricing in November 2026. Products change, so check the latest details.

Sources

Read next: Cookieless analytics next to your pages, SEO built into CMS Orbit and EU hosting, SSO and security.

Comparisons

CMS Orbit vs Hygraph: GraphQL federation or a complete website CMS

Hygraph is a GraphQL-native CMS built to federate content from other systems. CMS Orbit is a complete CMS for websites, with scheduling, SSO, an audit log, reviews, SEO and accessibility on every plan from €49. Hygraph keeps scheduling, SSO and audit logs for Enterprise.

12 min read

Comparisons

Commerce Orbit vs Shopify

Shopify is the default for online shops, and for good reasons. Commerce Orbit charges no fee per order, and its €39 and €149 plans include SSO, subscriptions and B2B price lists.

10 min read

See it with your own team.

Orbit is free. Try CMS Orbit for 14 days with your own content, no card needed, or ask us anything.

Talk to us